Progressive vs Insureon: Which Is Cheaper? (2026)

Quick Answer: Which is cheaper?

Progressive is a direct insurance carrier offering one quote ($30-50/mo GL). Best for commercial auto and fast, direct relationships.

Insureon is a marketplace comparing 15+ carriers (including Progressive). Average range: $25-80/mo GL. Often finds 15-30% savings.

Bottom line: This is apples vs oranges. Progressive sells insurance. Insureon compares 15+ carriers to find you the cheapest option (which might be Progressive or someone else).

Get quotes from both →

Feature	Progressive (Direct)	Insureon (Marketplace)
Price Range (GL)	$30-50/month (fixed)	$25-80/month (15+ carriers)
Quote Speed	Instant to 24 hours	1-3 days (multiple quotes)
Carriers Compared	1 (Progressive only)	15+ (Hartford, Hiscox, Chubb, etc.)
Broker Commission	None (direct)	10-15% built into premium
Best For	Commercial auto, direct relationships, speed	Finding cheapest option, niche industries, E&O coverage

Which is cheaper: Progressive or Insureon?

Quick verdict: This is comparing apples to oranges! Progressive is a carrier (sells insurance), Insureon is a marketplace (compares 15+ carriers, including Progressive).

Key differentiators:

Progressive Direct: One carrier, faster quotes, direct relationship, no broker fees, best for commercial auto
Insureon Marketplace: Multiple carriers compared, may show Progressive + 15 others, finds cheapest option, best for comparison shopping

Cost comparison snapshot:

Progressive Direct GL: $30-50/mo (fixed - their rate only)
Insureon GL Options: $25-80/mo (multiple carriers shown, including potentially Progressive at same $30-50/mo)

Bottom line: Use BOTH. Get Progressive's direct quote, then use Insureon to see if any of their 15+ carriers beat it. Insureon might even show you Progressive's policy alongside cheaper alternatives.

Compare multiple carriers in one place →

Real Business Scenarios

Scenario 1: Contractor Shopping for GL + Commercial Auto

Mike's Plumbing LLC (sole proprietor + 1 employee, 2 work trucks, $180K revenue)

Progressive Direct quote: $45/mo GL + $320/mo commercial auto (2 vehicles) = $365/mo total ($4,380/year)

Insureon marketplace results:

Progressive: $45/mo GL + $320/mo auto = $365/mo
The Hartford: $55/mo GL + $300/mo auto = $355/mo (saves $120/year)
Liberty Mutual: $50/mo GL + $285/mo auto = $335/mo (saves $360/year)

Winner: Insureon saved Mike $360/year by finding Liberty Mutual's better commercial auto rate

Why Insureon wins: Even though Progressive specializes in auto, Insureon found 2 carriers with better rates. Mike would have paid $360 more per year by only checking Progressive directly.

Scenario 2: Tech Startup Needing E&O + Cyber Insurance

CodeCraft Solutions (3 developers, $400K revenue)

Progressive Direct: Limited E&O options, directed to partner brokers for cyber insurance

Insureon marketplace results:

Hiscox: $65/mo E&O + $85/mo cyber = $150/mo ($1,800/year)
The Hartford: $95/mo comprehensive E&O + cyber bundle = $95/mo ($1,140/year)
Chubb: $120/mo premium E&O + cyber = $120/mo ($1,440/year)

Winner: Insureon marketplace found Hartford's bundle for $1,140/year

Why Insureon wins: Progressive doesn't specialize in professional services insurance. Insureon's marketplace instantly connected CodeCraft with carriers who do, showing 3 specialized options. Going through Progressive directly would have resulted in referrals to brokers anyway.

Scenario 3: Restaurant Needing BOP + Workers Comp

Bella's Bistro (owner + 8 employees, $620K revenue)

Progressive Direct quote: $180/mo BOP + $580/mo workers comp = $760/mo ($9,120/year)

Insureon marketplace results:

Progressive: $180/mo BOP + $580/mo workers comp = $760/mo
The Hartford: $210/mo comprehensive BOP + $550/mo workers comp = $760/mo (same price, better coverage)
Acuity: $165/mo BOP + $520/mo workers comp = $685/mo (saves $900/year)

Winner: Insureon found Acuity at $685/mo, saving $900/year with better restaurant-specific coverage

Why Insureon wins: Bella got to see Progressive's quote alongside 2 other options. Acuity specializes in restaurant insurance and offered better terms. The Hartford matched Progressive's price but with more comprehensive BOP coverage. Without Insureon's comparison, Bella would have simply accepted Progressive's quote.

Compare all your carrier options →

Key Takeaway:

You're not choosing between two insurance companies - you're choosing between getting one quote (Progressive) or comparing 15+ quotes (Insureon marketplace). The smartest strategy? Get both, then choose whichever saves you more money.

Quick Comparison: Direct vs Marketplace
Understanding the Two Models
How Pricing Works
What Affects Your Costs
Coverage Options Compared
Hidden Costs and Fees
Real-World Price Comparisons
When to Choose Progressive
When to Choose Insureon
Bottom Line
FAQ

Quick Decision Guide: Progressive vs Insureon

Factor	Progressive (Direct)	Insureon (Marketplace)
Business Model	Direct insurance carrier	Broker/marketplace (sells 15+ carriers)
Quote Comparison	One carrier only (Progressive)	15+ carriers including Progressive
Best For	Commercial auto, fast direct quotes	Finding cheapest option, niche industries
Quote Speed	Instant to 24 hours	1-3 business days (multiple quotes)
Pricing	Fixed (Progressive's rate)	Variable (shows all carrier options)
Broker Commission	None (direct)	Built into premium (standard 10-15%)
Coverage Options	Progressive products only	15+ carriers: Hartford, Hiscox, Chubb, etc.
Savings Potential	No comparison (might overpay)	Often finds 15-30% savings

Get quotes from both approaches →

Understanding the Two Models

When shopping for business insurance, U.S. small business owners often encounter two very different options: buying directly from a carrier like Progressive or using an online marketplace like Insureon. Understanding the pricing differences between these approaches can save you hundreds—or even thousands—of dollars annually while ensuring you get the right coverage for your business.

Progressive: The Direct Carrier

Progressive is an American insurance company that insures passenger vehicles, motorcycles, recreational vehicles, trailers, boats, and commercial vehicles [1].

Progressive is the second-largest auto insurer in the United States as of the 2023 fiscal year, with 15.2% of the market. While primarily known for personal auto insurance, Progressive also offers commercial insurance products directly to business owners [1].

Progressive's Strengths:

Direct relationship with your carrier
No broker middleman
Fast quotes (often instant)
Exceptional commercial auto expertise
Strong digital platform and mobile app

Insureon: The Insurance Marketplace

Insureon is an independent marketplace for online delivery of small business insurance, and its digital platform allows small-business owners to compare insurance quotes and buy coverage online [2].

Headquartered in Chicago, Insureon is the largest digital agency for small and medium-sized businesses, offering policies from the nation's top carriers, including Acuity, Chubb, The Hartford, Hiscox, Liberty Mutual, and Travelers [2].

Insureon's Strengths:

Compare 15+ carriers simultaneously
One application, multiple quotes
May show Progressive alongside competitors
Licensed agents guide you through options
Specialized coverage for niche industries

The Fundamental Difference: Progressive sells only Progressive insurance. Insureon sells insurance from 15+ carriers (potentially including Progressive). You're not choosing between two carriers - you're choosing between getting one quote or getting many quotes.

Compare multiple carriers instantly →

How Pricing Works: Direct Carrier vs Marketplace

Progressive's Direct Pricing Model

When you get a quote from Progressive, you're receiving pricing directly from the carrier.

The actuarial science of ratemaking uses statistics and probability to approximate the rate of future claims based on a given risk, and at the most basic level, initial rate-making involves looking at the frequency and severity of insured perils and the expected average payout resulting from these perils [3].

Progressive's pricing reflects their own underwriting criteria, claims experience, and risk appetite. You'll see one price—theirs—and you can either accept it or shop elsewhere on your own.

Direct Carrier Advantage: No broker commission markup. You control the relationship - direct claims handling, direct policy changes, and potential for multi-policy bundling discounts if you have Progressive personal insurance.

Insureon's Marketplace Pricing

Many institutional insurance purchasers buy insurance through an insurance broker, and a broker generally holds contracts with many insurers, thereby allowing the broker to "shop" the market for the best rates and coverage possible. This is exactly what Insureon does for small businesses [3].

When you request a quote through Insureon, you're actually getting quotes from multiple carriers simultaneously.

The company is licensed in 50 states, and specializes in numerous industries, from IT professionals to restaurants, with more than 1 million policies written [2].

Marketplace Advantage: Insureon shows you side-by-side pricing from 15+ carriers, potentially finding options 15-30% cheaper than any single carrier. Their licensed agents do the shopping for you.

Compare all your options →

What Affects Your Business Insurance Costs

Regardless of whether you choose Progressive or Insureon, several factors influence your premium. Understanding these can help you make apples-to-apples comparisons.

The region in which your business operates affects premiums, as insurers in areas prone to extreme weather such as hail, wind storms and hurricanes, or high-traffic, high-theft locations typically charge higher rates [4].

A high past-claims history can increase insurance costs, while choosing a plan with higher than average deductibles can lower premiums [4].

For a comprehensive breakdown of what influences your costs, check out our detailed business insurance cost guide.

Industry-Specific Pricing

Direct premiums written increased 10.5% to $529.0 billion in the first half of 2024 compared to $478.6 billion for the same period in 2023, with premium growth in the personal lines segment being the primary driver, increasing 14.9%. This market-wide trend affects both direct carriers and marketplace options [5].

Your industry significantly impacts pricing. A consulting firm will pay vastly different rates than a construction company, even for the same coverage limits. Progressive may specialize in certain industries where they offer competitive rates, while Insureon's multi-carrier approach might find better options for businesses in niche sectors.

Key Insight: Progressive excels at pricing commercial auto and straightforward GL. Insureon's marketplace shines for professional services, tech companies, and specialized industries where comparison shopping reveals significant savings.

Get personalized quotes →

Comparing Coverage Options

Business Owner's Policy (BOP) Pricing

A business owner's policy is a special type of commercial insurance designed for small and medium-sized businesses, and by bundling general liability insurance and property insurance into a single policy, BOPs typically offer a reduced premium, often making them a more cost-effective option than separately purchased policies [6].

Key Takeaway:

For commercial auto coverage, Progressive's direct quotes are often the most competitive. But for professional liability (E&O), cyber insurance, or specialized coverage, Insureon's marketplace will connect you with carriers that specialize in those areas - often at better rates than trying to force-fit Progressive.

Both Progressive and Insureon offer BOPs, but the pricing structure differs. Progressive will quote you their BOP rate, while Insureon can show you BOP options from multiple carriers side-by-side. For more details on BOP costs, see our [Business Owners Policy cost guide](https://insura.ai/articles/business-owners-policy-cost-guide).

You can also explore specific Business Owners Policy coverage options to understand what's included in these bundled packages.

Coverage Type	Progressive Direct	Insureon Marketplace Range
General Liability	$30-50/month	$25-80/month (15+ carrier options)
BOP (GL + Property)	$50-150/month	$40-200/month (carrier-dependent)
Commercial Auto	$100-200/vehicle	$95-250/vehicle (may include Progressive)
Workers' Comp	$60-140/month	$55-180/month (state/carrier specific)

Get BOP quotes now →

Workers' Compensation Insurance

All major commercial lines recorded premium growth, except for workers' compensation, where profitability and increased competition brought rates down. This is good news for small business owners shopping for workers' comp coverage [5].

Progressive offers workers' compensation in select states, while Insureon can connect you with multiple workers' comp carriers. Since workers' comp rates are heavily regulated and vary by state, the marketplace approach often reveals significant price differences between carriers.

Learn more about workers' compensation pricing in our Workers' Comp Insurance cost guide, or explore Workers' Comp coverage details to understand your obligations.

Workers' Comp Winner: Insureon's marketplace approach wins for workers' comp because rates vary dramatically by carrier and state. Comparing 5-10 carriers can save you 20-40% versus accepting the first quote.

Compare workers' comp rates →

Hidden Costs and Fees

Commission Structures

A broker's compensation comes in the form of a commission as a percentage of the insurance premium, creating a conflict of interest in that the broker's financial interest is tilted toward encouraging an insured to purchase more insurance than might be necessary at a higher price. This applies to Insureon as a broker [3].

Key Takeaway:

Broker commissions are built into the premium - you don't pay extra. If Insureon finds a carrier that's 20% cheaper than Progressive (even with commission), you still save money. Focus on total cost, not commission structure.

However, transparency has improved significantly. Insureon's online platform shows you multiple options with clear pricing, allowing you to make informed decisions. Progressive, as a direct carrier, doesn't pay broker commissions, but that doesn't automatically mean lower prices—they have their own overhead and profit margins built into premiums.

Transparency Note: Broker commissions (10-15%) are built into the premium - you don't pay extra. Often, the savings from finding a cheaper carrier through a broker exceed any commission cost. Always ask about additional policy fees beyond the quoted premium.

Administrative Fees

Some brokers charge policy fees or administrative fees on top of the premium. When comparing quotes, always ask about additional fees beyond the quoted premium. Progressive typically includes all costs in their quoted premium, while Insureon's fees (if any) should be clearly disclosed during the quote process.

Progressive Direct:

No broker commission
All costs in quoted premium
Potential policy fees for changes

Insureon Marketplace:

Broker commission built into premium (10-15%)
May have small policy fees ($25-50 annually)
Savings often exceed commission costs

Get transparent pricing →

Real-World Price Comparisons

While individual quotes vary dramatically based on your specific business, industry data provides context.

In a survey by the National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB), 30 percent of small business owners ranked the cost and availability of liability insurance as their second most important insurance concern, with health insurance ranked first and workers' compensation ranked third [4].

Typical Cost Ranges by Business Type

Business Type	Progressive Quote	Insureon Marketplace Range	Better Option
Consultant (GL + E&O)	Limited E&O options	$50-150/mo from Hiscox, Hartford, Chubb	Insureon (specialized options)
Contractor (GL + Auto)	$150-250/mo	$135-280/mo (compare to find best)	Compare both (often similar)
Retail Store (BOP)	$80-150/mo	$65-180/mo (varies by carrier)	Insureon (finds better BOP options)
Delivery Service (Auto-heavy)	$400-600/mo (multiple vehicles)	$380-650/mo	Progressive (auto expertise)

Progressive might offer competitive rates if your business profile matches their preferred risk categories. Insureon's advantage lies in showing you whether another carrier beats Progressive's price—sometimes by 20% or more.

See your real pricing →

When Progressive Makes Sense

Choose Progressive directly when:

1. You have simple, straightforward insurance needs
If you need basic commercial auto or a standard BOP, Progressive's streamlined process gets you covered quickly.

2. You're already a Progressive customer
Bundling business and personal insurance with the same carrier sometimes yields multi-policy discounts (5-15% savings).

3. You prefer dealing directly with your insurer
Some business owners value having a direct relationship with their carrier for claims and policy changes.

4. You need commercial auto coverage
Progressive specializes in commercial auto and often offers competitive rates for vehicle-based businesses. Their auto expertise is industry-leading.

5. Speed is your priority
Direct quotes from Progressive are typically faster (instant to 24 hours) than waiting for multiple marketplace quotes (1-3 days).

6. You want simplicity
One carrier, one relationship, no comparisons needed. Simple and fast.

Get a Progressive quote →

When Insureon Makes Sense

Choose Insureon when:

1. You want to compare multiple carriers at once
Instead of shopping each carrier individually, Insureon does the legwork for you. One application gets you 5-15 quotes.

2. You're in a niche industry
Insureon's diverse carrier network means better options for specialized businesses (tech companies, professional services, unusual industries).

3. Your business needs have changed
When your current policy expires, Insureon can help you re-evaluate all your options and find carriers specializing in your current situation.

4. You're looking for the absolute best price
The marketplace model often uncovers savings of 15-30% by comparing 15+ carriers. You might discover carriers you've never heard of with better rates.

5. You value expert guidance
Insureon's licensed agents can help you understand complex coverage needs and explain the differences between carrier options.

6. You need specialized coverage Progressive doesn't offer
Professional liability (E&O), cyber insurance, tech E&O, D&O insurance - Insureon connects you with carriers who specialize in these.

7. You want to see if Progressive is actually competitive
Insureon may show you Progressive's quote alongside 10+ others, proving whether Progressive is your best option or not.

Compare multiple carriers →

Bottom Line: The Smart Strategy

After analyzing both approaches, here's the most cost-effective strategy for small businesses:

The Winning Approach: Use BOTH

Step 1: Get Progressive's direct quote first (Fast - takes 10 minutes)

Instant online quote for GL, BOP, or commercial auto
See their pricing as your baseline
No obligation, no broker fees

Step 2: Run the same info through Insureon (Takes 15 minutes)

Compare Progressive's quote against 15+ other carriers
See if any carrier beats Progressive by 15% or more
Insureon might even show Progressive alongside competitors

Step 3: Choose the best option

If Progressive is cheapest: Buy direct and save broker commission
If another carrier is cheaper: Buy through Insureon and save 15-30%
If Progressive and others are similar: Decide based on carrier preference

When to Choose Each Option

Choose Progressive Direct if:

Their quote beats Insureon's options
You need commercial auto (Progressive's specialty)
You want a direct carrier relationship
You already have Progressive personal insurance (bundle discount)
Speed matters more than comparison shopping

Choose an Insureon Carrier if:

Any Insureon carrier beats Progressive by 10%+
You need specialized coverage (E&O, cyber, D&O)
You're in a niche industry
You want expert broker guidance
You value having multiple options

The Reality: Most savvy business owners get both quotes. It takes 25 minutes total and can save you $500-$2,000 per year.

Start comparing now - get both quotes →

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper: Progressive or Insureon?

This isn't an apples-to-apples comparison. Progressive is a carrier (one quote), Insureon is a marketplace (15+ quotes, possibly including Progressive). The "cheaper" option depends on which carrier wins for your specific business. Use both: get Progressive's direct quote, then use Insureon to see if any of their 15+ carriers beat it.

Can I get a quote online from both carriers?

Yes, both Progressive and Insureon offer online quote tools. Progressive's digital platform provides instant quotes for many business types. Insureon's platform connects you with multiple carriers, and quotes typically arrive within 1-3 business days depending on coverage complexity.

Which has better customer service?

Customer service preferences vary. Progressive offers extensive phone support, online account management, and a large agent network. Insureon provides licensed broker agents who can help you navigate multiple carrier options and answer questions about different policies. Both have solid reputations for different reasons.

How quickly can I get covered?

Progressive often provides coverage within 24-48 hours of approval for standard risks. Insureon's timeline depends on which carrier you select through their marketplace, typically 2-5 business days from quote acceptance to active policy.

Do both offer workers' compensation?

Yes, both offer workers' compensation insurance, though availability and pricing vary by state and industry. Progressive offers workers' comp in select states, while Insureon can connect you with multiple workers' comp carriers, which is particularly useful since rates vary significantly between carriers in many states.

Can Insureon actually sell me a Progressive policy?

Yes! Insureon is a marketplace that works with multiple carriers. While carrier availability varies, Insureon may offer Progressive policies alongside other options. This means you could potentially get a Progressive quote through Insureon while simultaneously comparing it to 10+ other carriers.

Does using a broker cost more?

Not necessarily. While brokers earn commissions (typically 10-15% of the premium), these commissions are usually built into the premium itself - you don't pay extra. In fact, brokers often find savings that more than offset any commission costs because they can compare multiple carriers. The carrier with a broker commission might still be 20% cheaper than Progressive direct.

Should I just use Insureon if it compares multiple carriers including Progressive?

Smart strategy: Use both. Get Progressive's direct quote first (faster, no broker fee if they're cheapest). Then use Insureon to verify you're getting the best deal. If another carrier through Insureon beats Progressive by 15%+, the broker commission is worth it for the savings.

Get Your Quotes Today

Ready to find the cheapest business insurance? The smart strategy is simple: compare both approaches.

Get quotes from Progressive, Insureon, and more →

Get instant online quotes, compare pricing side-by-side, and choose the insurance that offers the best value for your business.

Progressive vs Insureon: Which Is Cheaper? (2026)

Which is cheaper: Progressive or Insureon?

Real Business Scenarios

Scenario 1: Contractor Shopping for GL + Commercial Auto

Scenario 2: Tech Startup Needing E&O + Cyber Insurance

Scenario 3: Restaurant Needing BOP + Workers Comp

Table of Contents

Quick Decision Guide: Progressive vs Insureon

Understanding the Two Models

Progressive: The Direct Carrier

Insureon: The Insurance Marketplace

How Pricing Works: Direct Carrier vs Marketplace

Progressive's Direct Pricing Model

Insureon's Marketplace Pricing

What Affects Your Business Insurance Costs

Industry-Specific Pricing

Comparing Coverage Options

Business Owner's Policy (BOP) Pricing

Workers' Compensation Insurance

Hidden Costs and Fees

Commission Structures

Administrative Fees

Real-World Price Comparisons

Typical Cost Ranges by Business Type

When Progressive Makes Sense

When Insureon Makes Sense

Bottom Line: The Smart Strategy

The Winning Approach: Use BOTH

When to Choose Each Option

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper: Progressive or Insureon?

Can I get a quote online from both carriers?

Which has better customer service?

How quickly can I get covered?

Do both offer workers' compensation?

Can Insureon actually sell me a Progressive policy?

Does using a broker cost more?

Should I just use Insureon if it compares multiple carriers including Progressive?

Related Articles

Get Your Quotes Today

Sources