Quick Answer: Progressive offers more affordable commercial auto and general liability (20-30% cheaper) for contractors, trucking, and trades. Hiscox specializes in professional liability (E&O), cyber, and specialty coverage for consultants, tech companies, and creative businesses. Different target markets = both excel in their niches.

Compare personalized quotes →

🔍 Which Should You Choose?

Choose Progressive if:

✅ You have commercial vehicles or a fleet
✅ You're a contractor, landscaper, or trades business
✅ Budget is your #1 priority
✅ You need commercial auto + GL bundled

Choose Hiscox if:

✅ You're a consultant, tech startup, or professional services firm
✅ You need E&O or cyber insurance as primary coverage
✅ You value premium service and fast claim payouts
✅ Your industry requires specialized professional liability

Progressive vs Hiscox Small Business Insurance: A Comprehensive Comparison for U.S. Business Owners

Quick Answer: Progressive = multi-industry generalist with strong commercial auto (20-30% cheaper). Hiscox = professional services specialist with premium E&O and cyber coverage. Best for contractors: Progressive. Best for consultants/tech: Hiscox

Get your personalized quote

Quick Decision: Which Carrier Fits Your Business?

Factor	Progressive	Hiscox
Primary strength	Commercial auto, general business	Professional liability, specialty coverage
Best for	Contractors, delivery, retail, restaurants	Consultants, tech, creative professionals
Pricing	20-30% lower for basic coverage	Premium for specialized coverage
Quote speed	Online or agent, 1-3 days	1-5 days (specialty review)
Market position	7.13% P&C market share, #2 in U.S.	FTSE 100, Lloyd's underwriter

TL;DR: At a Glance Choose Progressive if:

You need commercial auto insurance (industry leader with 14.99% market share)
You're a contractor, delivery service, or retail business
Budget is a top priority—save 20-30% on standard coverage
You want bundled coverage options and multi-policy discounts
You prefer working with local agents or robust online tools Choose Hiscox if:
You're a consultant, tech company, or creative professional
You need specialized E&O or cyber liability coverage
Your contracts require high professional liability limits ($5M+)
You have unique risks (hacking, kidnapping, satellite damage)
You value Lloyd's of London underwriting expertise Cost comparison: Progressive's GL costs $50-150/month for standard businesses. Hiscox's E&O starts at $100-300/month but includes comprehensive professional liability tailored to your industry. >

Compare quotes and coverage

Why This Comparison Matters for Small Business Owners Choosing the right insurance provider is one of the most critical decisions you'll make as a small business owner. With more than half a million U.S. entrepreneurs starting a business each month, understanding your insurance options can mean the difference between long-term success and financial vulnerability [1]

Two prominent names in the small business insurance market—Progressive and Hiscox—offer distinctly different approaches to protecting your enterprise. This comprehensive comparison will help you understand which insurer better aligns with your business needs, budget, and risk profile.

Understanding the Two Insurers: Background and Market Position

Progressive Corporation: American Insurance Giant Progressive is the second-largest auto insurer in the United States as of the 2023 fiscal year, with 15.2% of the market [2]

Key facts about Progressive:

Founded: 1937
Market position: #2 auto insurer in U.S.
Segments: Personal lines, commercial auto, other indemnity
Specialty: Commercial auto insurance and fleet coverage
Approach: Technology-driven with agent support The company operates in three segments: personal lines, commercial auto, and other indemnity, making it a major player in the small business insurance space [2]

Hiscox Ltd.: Lloyd's Specialist Underwriter Hiscox takes a different approach. An Anglo-Bermudan insurance provider listed on the London Stock Exchange, Hiscox is an underwriter at Lloyd's of London that largely specialises in niche areas of the market, offering property and casualty insurance aimed at companies and high-net-worth individuals [3]

Key facts about Hiscox:

Founded: 1901 (Lloyd's of London roots)
Market position: FTSE 100 component
Specialty: Niche coverage areas (cyber, E&O, unique risks)
Approach: Specialized underwriting for complex risks
Coverage: Hacking, kidnapping, satellite damage, traditional small business policies With roots dating back to 1901, Hiscox has cultivated expertise in specialized coverage areas that many traditional insurers avoid [3]

Ready to compare? Get instant quotes from both carriers

Coverage Options: Breadth vs. Specialization

Progressive's Commercial Insurance Portfolio Progressive's strength lies in its commercial auto insurance, which forms the backbone of its business insurance offerings. Progressive provides:

Commercial Auto Insurance: Primary liability and physical damage for business vehicles
Business Owner's Policies (BOP): Bundled coverage with GL and property insurance
Workers' Compensation: Available in select states
General Liability Insurance: Protection against third-party claims
Commercial Property: Building and inventory coverage
Inland Marine: Tools and equipment protection Progressive's commercial auto segment is particularly robust, offering coverage for various vehicle types from small business cars to commercial trucks. Commercial auto specifics:
Typical liability limits: $1 million+
Covers rented and non-owned vehicles
Includes employees' cars driven for company business [1]

Hiscox's Specialized Coverage Approach Hiscox differentiates itself through specialized, niche coverage options that cater to specific industries and unique risks. The company offers cover against such risks as hacking, kidnapping and satellite damage, alongside more traditional small business policies [3]

Hiscox's coverage portfolio includes:

Professional Liability Insurance: E&O coverage for service-based businesses
Cyber Liability Insurance: Data breaches and cyber attacks
Business Owner's Policies: Customized for specific industries
General Liability Insurance: Tailored to professional service providers
Media Liability: Content creators and digital businesses
Tech E&O: Source code protection and technology failures
Pollution Liability: Environmental contractors For small businesses in professional services, technology, or creative industries, Hiscox's specialized approach often provides more comprehensive protection for industry-specific risks. >

Get quotes in 60 seconds

Business Owner's Policies: The Foundation of Small Business Insurance A business owner's policy (BOP) is a "package" product that typically includes property, business interruption/continuation and liability insurance. For many small businesses, purchasing a BOP can be a less costly option than buying individual policies [1]

Progressive's BOP Progressive's BOP tends to be more standardized and straightforward, making it easier for businesses with conventional needs to obtain quick quotes and coverage. Best for:

Businesses requiring strong commercial auto coverage
Standard operations with conventional risks
Multi-location businesses needing consistent coverage
Those seeking bundled discounts

Hiscox's BOP Hiscox's BOP is more customizable and industry-specific. Many insurers customize BOPs for specific types of businesses, and Hiscox excels in this area, offering tailored policies for:

Consultants and advisory firms
Technology companies and IT services
Creative professionals (designers, agencies)
Specialized service businesses [1]

BOP statistics:

Eligibility: Companies with 100 or fewer employees with revenues up to $5 million
Market penetration: Estimated 30-40% of small business owners carry business interruption insurance [4]

Coverage Comparison by Business Type

Business Type	Progressive	Hiscox	Winner
Contractors	Strong auto & GL	Limited auto	Progressive
Consultants	Basic E&O	Specialized E&O	Hiscox
Tech/IT	Standard coverage	Tech E&O + cyber	Hiscox
Retail	Affordable BOP	Specialty retail	Depends on needs
Restaurants	Comprehensive BOP	Limited options	Progressive
Creative agencies	Basic coverage	Media liability	Hiscox

Compare rates side-by-side: Get personalized quotes now

Which Is Better for Contractors? Construction and trades businesses have specific insurance needs that favor Progressive's offerings.

Progressive for Contractors:

Industry-leading commercial auto insurance

for work vehicles

Tools and equipment coverage endorsements
Inland marine coverage for mobile equipment
Fleet pricing for multiple trucks/vans
24/7 claims reporting for job site incidents
Builder's risk insurance options
20-30% cheaper for standard GL coverage

Hiscox for Contractors:

Limited commercial auto options
Professional liability for design-build contractors
Pollution liability for environmental contractors
Higher premiums for standard GL coverage Verdict: For most contractors, Progressive's expertise in commercial auto and competitive pricing make it the clear winner. Get contractors insurance quotes

now.

Which Is Better for Professional Services and Tech Companies? For consultants, IT professionals, and creative agencies, Hiscox generally provides superior coverage.

Hiscox for Professional Services:

Industry-specific professional liability insurance
Comprehensive cyber liability coverage
Media liability for content creators
Technology E&O with source code protection
Underwriters who understand professional services
Policy language tailored to consultants
High limits available ($10M+)

Progressive for Professional Services:

Lower-cost basic general liability
Limited professional liability options
E&O available but less specialized
Cyber coverage as add-on only
Standard policy language Verdict: For consultants, tech startups, and creative professionals, Hiscox's specialized professional liability insurance

offers better protection for your unique risks. >

Need coverage today? Get quotes in 60 seconds

Industry-Specific Considerations

Best for Transportation and Logistics Businesses Winner: Progressive If your business relies heavily on vehicles—whether you operate a delivery service, transportation company, or any business with a fleet—Progressive's deep expertise in commercial auto insurance makes it the stronger choice. Why Progressive wins:

Extensive experience in commercial auto sector
Competitive pricing for fleet coverage
Comprehensive coverage options for all vehicle types
24/7 claims support for vehicle incidents

Best for Retail Businesses Depends on retail type Progressive for retail when:

Brick-and-mortar with delivery operations
Multiple locations needing bundled coverage
Standard inventory and property exposures
Budget is primary concern Hiscox for retail when:
E-commerce with cyber liability needs
Specialty products requiring product liability
International shipping operations
High-value inventory requiring specialized coverage Explore retail business insurance

options for your store type.

Best for Hospitality Progressive for hospitality businesses like restaurants and bars needing:

Comprehensive BOP packages
Commercial auto for delivery operations
Competitive pricing for standard coverage
24/7 claims support
Liquor liability options See our guide to restaurant insurance

requirements and coverage options.

Pricing and Affordability Pricing in small business insurance varies dramatically based on numerous factors. Insurance companies weigh a variety of factors including insurers also taking into account special business-related factors that make one type of business more physically "risky" than another [1]

Progressive Pricing Progressive generally offers competitive pricing for businesses that fit standard risk profiles, particularly those requiring commercial auto coverage. Typical costs:

General Liability: $50-150/month
BOP: $75-200/month
Commercial Auto: $100-300/month per vehicle
Workers' Comp: Varies by state and payroll Why it's cheaper:
Large market share spreads risk efficiently
Standardized underwriting processes
Lower premiums for conventional businesses

Hiscox Pricing Hiscox typically commands higher premiums, but this often reflects more comprehensive coverage for specialized risks. Typical costs:

Professional Liability (E&O): $100-300/month
Cyber Liability: $75-250/month
BOP: $150-400/month
Specialized coverage: Custom pricing Why it costs more:
Specialized underwriting expertise
Comprehensive coverage for unique risks
Lloyd's of London backing
Higher limits available For businesses in professional services or those requiring cyber liability coverage, Hiscox's pricing may actually represent better value when comparing coverage breadth. According to

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics

data, insurance costs represent a significant expense for small businesses, making careful comparison essential. >

Need help choosing? Compare coverage options

Digital Experience and Customer Service

Progressive's Technology Platform Progressive was the first auto insurance company to:

Allow customers to purchase policies over the phone (1993)
Have a website (1995)
Have policies available for purchase online (1997)
Enable mobile browsers and smartphone apps for policy management
Offer 24/7 claims reporting [2]

Progressive's digital offerings:

Online quote generation
Digital policy management
Mobile app for claims filing
24/7 customer support
Agent network for personalized service This technological leadership extends to their commercial insurance products, providing a seamless experience for tech-savvy business owners.

Hiscox's Service Model Hiscox combines digital convenience with personalized service, particularly for complex coverage needs. Hiscox's service approach:

Online quote tools for standard policies
Access to specialized underwriters for complex risks
Dedicated account management for larger policies
Industry-specific expertise
Customized policy language For straightforward coverage needs, Progressive's fully digital approach may be more convenient. For businesses requiring specialized coverage or policy customization, Hiscox's hybrid model often provides better support.

Claims Handling and Reputation Claims handling represents the true test of any insurance provider. Both companies have faced scrutiny over their claims processes, but with different contexts.

Progressive Claims Handling Progressive has built a reputation for efficient claims processing, particularly for auto-related claims. Strengths:

Large claims department
Established processes for standard claims
Typically faster resolution for routine claims
24/7 claims reporting
Mobile app for easy claim filing

Hiscox Claims Handling Hiscox faced significant challenges during the COVID-19 pandemic regarding business interruption claims. The UK Supreme Court ruled in favour of Hiscox customers who had challenged the company's decision to exclude coronavirus-related disruptions from its business interruption policies. What this means:

Highlights complexity of policy language
Importance of understanding coverage limitations
Need to read policy documents carefully before purchasing Hiscox strengths:
Specialized expertise for complex claims
Understanding of professional liability claims
Dedicated adjusters for specialty coverage For insight into Progressive's overall performance, check our Progressive business insurance review