AmTrust vs Next Insurance (2026): Traditional Carrier vs Digital Disruptor

Quick Answer

AmTrust excels at workers' compensation for a wide range of industries including hard-to-place risks, while Next Insurance provides the fastest online quoting experience with competitive pricing for straightforward small business GL and BOP needs.

Cost: $400-$2,000/year for micro-businesses, $2,000-$8,000 for small businesses (5-20 employees), $8,000-$20,000+ for larger or higher-risk firms

Best for:

AmTrust: Businesses needing workers' comp in hard-to-place industries, restaurants, staffing agencies, and companies with complex payroll structures
Next Insurance: Sole proprietors and small businesses with 1-25 employees needing GL, BOP, or professional liability with instant online purchase

Bottom line: Next Insurance wins for speed and simplicity if you have a straightforward small business. AmTrust is the better choice for workers' comp-focused needs and businesses that struggle to find coverage with digital carriers.

Get instant quotes from top carriers →

⚡ Why use a brokerage platform instead of buying direct? These carriers let you buy directly — but you'll only see that one carrier's price. A brokerage platform like Insura shops 10+ carriers behind the scenes to find the lowest rate for your exact business. The price you pay is the same whether you buy direct or through a broker — carriers pay the broker's commission, not you.

AmTrust Financial Services and Next Insurance represent the old and new guard of small business insurance. AmTrust, founded in 1998, has built a massive workers' compensation and small commercial book through its network of agents and managing general agents (MGAs), serving hundreds of thousands of businesses with a particular strength in industries that other carriers find difficult to underwrite. Next Insurance, founded in 2016, has rapidly grown into one of the largest insurtech carriers by making it possible for small business owners to get coverage in minutes through a fully digital platform.

The choice between these two carriers often depends on the complexity of your business and your preferred buying experience. If you need specialized workers' comp coverage or operate in an industry that digital carriers have difficulty underwriting, AmTrust's deep bench of underwriting expertise is invaluable. If you run a straightforward small business and want to buy coverage quickly online at a competitive price, Next Insurance has streamlined the process like no other carrier.

Get instant quotes from top carriers →

Quick Comparison Overview

Feature	AmTrust	Next Insurance
Best For	Workers' comp specialists, hard-to-place risks, restaurants	Sole proprietors, contractors, simple small businesses
Online Quote	Via agents and select platforms	Yes (instant, fully digital)
Policy Types	GL, BOP, WC, Commercial Package, Cyber, E&O, EPLI	GL, BOP, WC, Commercial Auto, Professional Liability, Cyber
GL Starting Price	$500-$1,200/year	$300-$700/year
Claims Process	24/7 phone, specialized adjusters	Online portal, email-based, phone available
Customer Rating	3.8/5 (mixed reviews)	4.3/5 (online reviews)
AM Best Rating	A- (Excellent)	A- (Excellent, via affiliates)
Discounts	Multi-policy, claims-free, pay-as-you-go WC	Multi-policy, pay-in-full, monthly billing available

Get instant quotes from top carriers →

Coverage Options Compared

AmTrust's product portfolio is anchored by workers' compensation, which accounts for a significant portion of their premium volume. Their workers' comp appetite is notably broader than most carriers, extending to industries like staffing, restaurants, janitorial services, and light manufacturing that many competitors avoid or price prohibitively. Beyond workers' comp, AmTrust offers general liability, business owner's policies, commercial package policies, professional liability, employment practices liability (EPLI), and cyber coverage. Their EPLI product is particularly strong, covering claims related to wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, and wage disputes.

Next Insurance has built a streamlined product suite designed for the most common small business needs. Their offerings include general liability, business owner's policies, professional liability, workers' compensation (available in most states), commercial auto, and a newer cyber liability product. Next Insurance's underwriting is largely automated, using data-driven models to assess risk and generate quotes without human intervention for most business types. This automation enables their trademark speed but also means they have less flexibility for unusual or complex risks.

The fundamental difference is flexibility versus speed. AmTrust can accommodate a wider range of business types and risk profiles because they employ human underwriters who can evaluate nuanced situations. Next Insurance trades some of that flexibility for a dramatically faster and simpler purchasing experience. If your business fits neatly into common industry categories like handyman, cleaning service, personal trainer, photographer, or general contractor, Next Insurance will likely have you covered. If your business has unusual characteristics, a complex payroll structure, or operates in an industry that requires specialized underwriting judgment, AmTrust is more likely to find a way to provide coverage.

Both carriers have expanded their digital capabilities in recent years. AmTrust has invested in online quoting platforms through its MGA partnerships, though the experience is not as polished as Next Insurance's purpose-built platform. Next Insurance continues to expand its appetite to include more business types and coverage lines.

Pricing Breakdown

Coverage Type	AmTrust	Next Insurance
General Liability	$500-$2,800/year	$300-$2,000/year
Business Owner's Policy	$1,000-$4,000/year	$600-$3,000/year
Workers' Compensation	$1,000-$5,500/year (5 employees)	$1,200-$5,000/year (5 employees, select states)
Professional Liability (E&O)	$700-$3,500/year	$500-$2,500/year
Cyber Liability	$800-$3,000/year	$500-$1,500/year
Commercial Auto	Via partner carriers	$1,200-$4,000/vehicle/year

Next Insurance is typically more competitive on general liability and BOP pricing for straightforward, low-risk small businesses. Their automated underwriting eliminates much of the overhead that traditional carriers build into their rates, and they pass some of those savings on to customers. For a sole proprietor or small business with fewer than 10 employees in a common industry, Next Insurance often delivers the lowest available rate.

AmTrust's pricing advantage emerges in workers' compensation, particularly for businesses in industries where their specialized underwriting allows them to offer coverage that other carriers decline or price punitively. A staffing agency, restaurant, or janitorial service might find that AmTrust's workers' comp rate is 10-30% lower than what they can get elsewhere, simply because AmTrust understands these industries well enough to price risk more accurately.

For a cleaning business with 8 employees and $400,000 in annual payroll, expect workers' comp quotes of roughly $3,500-$6,000 from AmTrust and $4,000-$7,000 from Next Insurance (where available). For the same business's GL needs, Next Insurance might quote $600-$1,200 compared to AmTrust's $900-$1,800.

Claims Process & Customer Service

AmTrust's claims operation handles a high volume of workers' compensation claims, and their adjusters have deep experience managing workplace injury cases across a wide range of industries. They offer 24/7 claims reporting by phone and provide nurse case management for complex injuries. However, AmTrust's customer service reviews are mixed, with some policyholders reporting slower response times and longer claims resolution than expected. The company has invested in improving their claims experience in recent years, but they still lag behind some competitors in policyholder satisfaction surveys.

Next Insurance's claims process is designed to be as digital as their purchasing experience. Claims can be filed through their online portal or mobile app, and straightforward claims are often processed within days. Next Insurance has received generally positive reviews for claims handling, with particular praise for transparency and communication. Their customer service team is accessible via phone, email, and chat, and response times tend to be fast. However, for complex claims that require in-depth investigation, some policyholders have noted that Next Insurance's lean claims operation can feel less hands-on than a traditional carrier.

Both carriers hold A- (Excellent) AM Best ratings, ensuring financial stability for claims payment. Neither carrier is at risk of being unable to pay legitimate claims.

Pros and Cons

AmTrust Pros

Broadest workers' comp appetite in the market, covering industries other carriers avoid
Deep underwriting expertise for complex and hard-to-place risks
Strong EPLI and specialty coverage options beyond standard commercial lines
Flexible underwriting with human judgment for nuanced risk assessments

AmTrust Cons

Mixed customer service reviews with some reports of slower claims handling
Online quoting experience is less polished than Next Insurance's platform
Higher GL and BOP pricing for straightforward, low-risk businesses
Distribution primarily through agents and MGAs, less direct-to-customer access

Next Insurance Pros

Industry-leading digital experience with quotes in minutes and instant certificate issuance
Competitive pricing for GL, BOP, and professional liability for common business types
High customer satisfaction scores with transparent, efficient claims handling
Commercial auto coverage available, which many digital carriers lack

Next Insurance Cons

Limited appetite for complex, unusual, or high-risk businesses
Workers' comp not available in all states
Automated underwriting means less flexibility for nuanced risk situations
Newer carrier with less track record than AmTrust's decades of experience

Which Should You Choose?

Choose AmTrust if your primary need is workers' compensation, especially if you operate in an industry like staffing, restaurants, janitorial services, or manufacturing where traditional digital carriers may not offer competitive rates or may decline coverage entirely. AmTrust's specialized underwriting expertise means they can often find a way to cover businesses that other carriers cannot, and their workers' comp pricing for these industries is among the most competitive available.

Choose Next Insurance if you run a common small business like a cleaning service, personal training business, photography studio, handyman operation, or consulting firm and want the fastest, simplest way to get covered. Next Insurance's digital platform delivers quotes in minutes, certificates instantly, and claims processing that matches the speed modern business owners expect. If your business profile fits their underwriting appetite, you will likely get a competitive rate with a superior customer experience.

Compare both if your business has needs that span both carriers' strengths, such as competitive workers' comp rates and a simple digital experience for other coverage lines. You may find that splitting your coverage between AmTrust for workers' comp and Next Insurance for GL or BOP delivers the best total value.

Why Compare Multiple Carriers?

Even between AmTrust and Next Insurance, rates and coverage vary significantly based on your industry, location, and risk profile. The smartest approach is to compare quotes from multiple carriers side-by-side.

At Insura.ai, we compare rates from 20+ top carriers including AmTrust, Next Insurance, and others — so you can find the best coverage at the best price in under 60 seconds.

Get instant quotes from top carriers →

Why Use a Brokerage Platform Instead of Buying Direct?

When a carrier offers instant quote-and-bind on their website, it's convenient — but you're only seeing one carrier's rates. A brokerage platform like Insura changes that equation:

One application, multiple quotes. Fill out one form and get compared across 10+ A-rated carriers including Hartford, Chubb, Hiscox, and more. No need to re-enter your business info on five different websites.
The price is the same — or lower. Carriers pay the broker's commission directly. Your premium is identical to what you'd pay buying direct, and often lower because a broker can find a carrier that prices your specific risk more competitively.
We work for you, not the carrier. A direct carrier's website is designed to sell you their policy. A brokerage platform is designed to find you the best policy — we have no incentive to push one carrier over another.
Automated comparison shopping, year after year. When your policy renews, a brokerage platform automatically re-shops your coverage across carriers to make sure you're still getting the best rate. Buy direct, and you're locked into one carrier's renewal pricing with no leverage.
Licensed experts when you need them. Have a coverage question or need help with a claim? You get access to real brokers — not a carrier's customer service line reading from a script.

→ Get your free multi-carrier quote

Don't limit yourself to one carrier's price. Insura compares Hartford, Chubb, Hiscox, and 20+ other carriers — the price is the same or less, and you'll know you got the best deal. Get your free multi-carrier quote →